Toronto Roofes Ltd vs Toronto HD.Roofing: which one for waterproofing?
Toronto Roofes Ltd and Toronto HD.Roofing both show up as solid options for waterproofing work in the Toronto area, but they earn their reputations on different parts of the job. This comparison, built on our methodology, looks at leak diagnosis track record, flat roof experience, warranty backing, and how each crew communicates once water is the problem.
The differences that matter
- Leak diagnosis focus. Toronto Roofes Ltd's praise centers specifically on leak diagnosis and shingle work, while Toronto HD.Roofing's strength is broader, spanning flat roofs, replacements, and skylights.
- Flat roof and skylight experience. Toronto HD.Roofing is specifically called out for completing flat roof and skylight jobs cleanly, which matters more for waterproofing than shingle-focused work does.
- Warranty backing. Toronto Roofes Ltd offers a 30-year warranty on shingle work, a concrete guarantee that Toronto HD.Roofing's listed praise does not mention.
- Track record depth. Toronto HD.Roofing's rating rests on 58 reviews versus 17 for Toronto Roofes Ltd, giving it a wider sample of waterproofing-adjacent jobs to judge from.
- Post-job reachability. Toronto Roofes Ltd's summary shows no complaints about follow-up, while Toronto HD.Roofing has one noted instance of difficulty reaching the owner after a job finished.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Toronto Roofes ltd: 5 (17 reviews)
- TORONTO HD.ROOFING: 4.7 (58 reviews)
- Services
- Toronto Roofes ltd: emergency 24 7, residential roofing, roof replacement installation, roof repair
- TORONTO HD.ROOFING: roof repair, roofing contractor, residential roofing, flat roofing
- Best for
- Toronto Roofes ltd: Diagnosing and fixing active leaks with documented photo tracking
- TORONTO HD.ROOFING: Flat roofs and skylights where water pooling is the core risk
- Root-cause approach
- Toronto Roofes ltd: Fast diagnosis backed by CertainTeed Master Shingle Applicator certification
- TORONTO HD.ROOFING: Noted for finding root causes other contractors miss
- Verification
- Toronto Roofes ltd: Google-verified
- TORONTO HD.ROOFING: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Toronto Roofes ltd: 83
- TORONTO HD.ROOFING: 82
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Toronto Roofes ltd
Alex and his team consistently earn five-star ratings for leak diagnosis, shingle replacement, and gutter work done with precision and care. They keep job sites clean, send photo updates throughout, and stick to timelines and pricing, earning trust across dozens of repeat referrals.
TORONTO HD.ROOFING
Henry and his crew deliver consistent, professional roofing work across flat roofs, replacements, repairs, and gutter services. They finish on time and budget, keep sites clean, and follow up after jobs. One reviewer noted difficulty reaching the owner later on; another had a brief communication issue years ago. The bulk of feedback centres on competent craftsmanship, honest pricing, and genuine care.
Which should you pick?
Pick Toronto Roofes ltd if
- You have an active leak or shingle roof and want fast, documented diagnosis with photo updates
- You want a long warranty (30 years) backing the waterproofing repair
- You value a smaller crew with a tight, consistent five-star track record
Pick TORONTO HD.ROOFING if
- Your waterproofing issue involves a flat roof or skylight rather than shingles
- You want a contractor with a larger volume of completed jobs (58 reviews) to judge consistency from
- You're comfortable with pricing transparency and hands-on service, and can plan around potential post-job follow-up delays
Verdict
The right pick depends on where the water is getting in. Toronto Roofes Ltd fits leak-driven, shingle-roof waterproofing where fast diagnosis, photo documentation, and a 30-year warranty matter most. Toronto HD.Roofing fits flat roof and skylight waterproofing, where its specific experience finding root causes and its larger job history carry more weight than a slightly higher composite score would suggest on its own.
Need help deciding which contractor suits your project?
Describe your roofing work once and compare quotes from qualified roofing contractor in Ontario.
When you submit a quote or contact form through this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work. We may earn a referral fee from these partners, but our rankings and scores are determined solely by our published method and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which contractor is better for a leaking shingle roof?
- Toronto Roofes Ltd's praise is built specifically around leak diagnosis and shingle work, backed by CertainTeed Master Shingle Applicator certification and a 30-year warranty.
- Which contractor has more experience with flat roofs?
- Toronto HD.Roofing is specifically noted for completing flat roof and skylight jobs cleanly, which are common sources of waterproofing problems.
- Does either contractor offer a warranty on waterproofing work?
- Toronto Roofes Ltd lists a 30-year warranty on shingle work. Toronto HD.Roofing's listed praise does not mention a specific warranty term.
- Are there any communication concerns with either contractor?
- Toronto HD.Roofing has one noted instance of difficulty reaching the owner after job completion and a prior communication incident; Toronto Roofes Ltd's summary shows no such complaints.