BNS Roofing vs Outstanding Roofing: which for gutter work?
BNS Roofing and Outstanding Roofing are both genuine options if you're calling around for gutter service in Ontario, and both come up clean on honesty and no-pressure sales in our methodology. The real question for gutters specifically is whether you want a flat-roof specialist who also handles gutters, or a crew whose review record names gutters as a core, standalone line of work.
The differences that matter
- Gutters named directly. Outstanding Roofing's review summary explicitly lists gutters alongside shingle/metal replacement, flashing, vents, and fascia, while BNS Roofing's summary centers on flat roof jobs and leak repairs without gutters called out.
- Review volume and confidence. BNS Roofing has more reviews behind its score (163 vs. 103) and a slightly higher volume sub-score (0.96 vs. 0.88), giving its 5-star record a bit more depth to lean on.
- Insurance and documentation support. Outstanding Roofing's praise specifically calls out insurance claim support and before-and-after photos, useful if gutter damage ties into a broader claim, whereas BNS Roofing's documentation is described as photo-based work records rather than claims help.
- Consultation style. BNS Roofing is built around owner-led consultations (Silvi and Keno personally, often same-day), while Outstanding Roofing runs a small named crew (Peter, Drieu, Mike) with fast response and on-the-spot problem-solving.
- Composite score edge. BNS Roofing edges out on overall composite score (93.3 vs. 91.3), driven mainly by its larger review volume rather than a sentiment gap, since both sit at 0.81 sentiment.
Side by side
- Google rating
- BNS Roofing: 5 (163 reviews)
- Outstanding roofing: 5 (103 reviews)
- Services
- BNS Roofing: roof repair, roofing contractor, residential roofing, flat roofing
- Outstanding roofing: roof repair, emergency 24 7, roofing contractor, residential roofing
- Gutter-specific experience
- BNS Roofing: Not named as a core specialty; work centers on flat roofs and leak repairs
- Outstanding roofing: Named directly in review summary alongside flashing, fascia, and vent work
- Best for
- BNS Roofing: Homeowners who want an owner-led, no-upsell inspection before committing to any roof work
- Outstanding roofing: Jobs where gutters are part of a wider repair or insurance claim needing documentation
- Verification
- BNS Roofing: Google-verified
- Outstanding roofing: Google-verified
- Composite score
- BNS Roofing: 93
- Outstanding roofing: 91
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
BNS Roofing
Every reviewer mentions speed, honesty, or the team's willingness to do inspections rather than push replacements. Flat roof jobs and leak repairs dominate the work; Silvi and Keno handle consultations personally, often same-day or within a week. Crews show up on time, clean after themselves, and document work with photos.
East York and North York customers specifically praise BNS for being the only contractor that wouldn't upsell them into unnecessary full replacements. Staff take pride in the craft and clearly enjoy dealing with homeowners who trust them. Price is repeatedly called reasonable or good for the quality delivered.
Outstanding roofing
Peter and his team earn consistent praise for turning up on time, completing work fast, and charging fairly. Every review mentions specific strengths: they explain what needs doing, refuse unnecessary upsells, answer questions readily, and leave yards cleaner than they found them.
The crew handles shingle and metal roof replacement, roof repairs, gutters, flashing, vents, fascia, and attic work with visible precision. Reviewers highlight insurance claim support, detailed before-and-after photos, and solving problems on the spot. Staff names Peter, Drieu, and Mike appear across jobs spanning months with no service hiccups reported.
Which should you pick?
Pick BNS Roofing if
- You want the owner (Silvi or Keno) personally involved in the consultation, often same-day
- Your gutter issue might really be a flat roof or leak problem that needs an honest second opinion first
- You want a contractor with a larger, deeper review history to check before booking
Pick Outstanding roofing if
- You know it's a gutter job and want a crew with gutters explicitly on their service list
- You're also dealing with flashing, fascia, or vent issues that could bundle with gutter work
- You may need insurance claim documentation alongside the repair
Verdict
For gutter service specifically, Outstanding Roofing is the better fit on paper, since gutters appear directly in its review record next to flashing and fascia work, and its insurance claim support is a real plus if damage assessment is involved. BNS Roofing still deserves a call if you're not fully sure the problem is gutters and not a flat roof or leak issue, since its owner-led, no-upsell inspections are built exactly for that kind of diagnosis, and it carries the deeper review history of the two.
Need help deciding which contractor suits your project?
Describe your roofing work once and compare quotes from qualified roofing contractor in Ontario.
When you submit a quote or contact form through this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work. We may earn a referral fee from these partners, but our rankings and scores are determined solely by our published method and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which company has more experience specifically with gutters?
- Outstanding Roofing's review summary names gutters directly as part of its regular work, alongside flashing, fascia, and vents. BNS Roofing's summary focuses on flat roofs and leak repairs and doesn't call out gutters by name.
- Which has the higher overall score?
- BNS Roofing scores 93.3 versus Outstanding Roofing's 91.3, mainly because BNS has a larger review volume (163 vs. 103 reviews) behind an equally strong 5-star rating.
- Does either company help with insurance claims for gutter damage?
- Outstanding Roofing's praise specifically mentions insurance claim support and before-and-after photo documentation. That isn't mentioned in BNS Roofing's review data.
- Who should I call if I'm not sure whether it's a gutter or roof problem?
- BNS Roofing is built around owner-led, no-pressure inspections from Silvi or Keno, often same-day, which suits a situation where you need an honest diagnosis before knowing what work is actually needed.