DVC Aluminum vs Blackstar Aluminum: which siding contractor wins?
DVC Aluminum and Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto are both genuine options if you're lining up a siding job in the Toronto area, but they win on different strengths. This comparison follows our methodology and focuses on what actually matters when the work in question is siding.
The differences that matter
- Owner-run vs crew-based. DVC is built around Vedran personally handling quotes and jobs, while Blackstar sends named technicians (Pat, Pierre, Alex, Horacio) as part of a larger team.
- Turnaround speed. DVC responds to quotes within 24 hours and often gets siding jobs done same-day or next-day, while Blackstar's jobs typically run one to two days.
- Job-site care and finish. Blackstar reviewers specifically call out protective protocols around existing metal roofs, landscaping, and structural elements plus a clean finish, a detail DVC's feedback doesn't emphasize the same way.
- Rating consistency at volume. DVC holds a perfect 5.0 across 170 reviews, while Blackstar's 4.8 across 227 reviews reflects a larger volume with slightly more variation.
- Scope beyond siding. Blackstar's siding work is described as refinishing that changes a home's appearance, alongside its established gutter guard systems, while DVC's siding sits alongside eavestrough and soffit/fascia as one of several core trades.
Side by side
- Google rating
- DVC Aluminum - Eavestrough, Soffit/Fascia, Siding: 5 (170 reviews)
- Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto: 4.8 (227 reviews)
- Services
- DVC Aluminum - Eavestrough, Soffit/Fascia, Siding: eavestrough gutters, siding contractor, roofing contractor, skylight contractor
- Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto: eavestrough gutters, gutter service, siding contractor, sheet metal contractor
- Best for
- DVC Aluminum - Eavestrough, Soffit/Fascia, Siding: Homeowners who want one person accountable start to finish and a fast quote-to-install timeline
- Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto: Jobs where crew coordination, site protection, and a polished cosmetic refinish matter
- Specialties
- DVC Aluminum - Eavestrough, Soffit/Fascia, Siding: Eavestrough, soffit/fascia, siding as a tight trio with quick scheduling
- Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto: Siding refinishes, gutter guards, and repair work backed by a multi-person crew
- Verification
- DVC Aluminum - Eavestrough, Soffit/Fascia, Siding: Google-verified
- Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto: Google-verified
- Composite score
- DVC Aluminum - Eavestrough, Soffit/Fascia, Siding: 94
- Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto: 91
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
DVC Aluminum - Eavestrough, Soffit/Fascia, Siding
Vedran responds to quotes within 24 hours and schedules jobs within days, often completing work the next day or same day. Customers consistently report professional service, fair prices, and attention to detail across eavestrough, siding, soffit, and downspout work.
Reviewers name Vedran by first name repeatedly, noting his willingness to listen, answer questions, and stand behind estimates. No complaints appear across recent reviews; repeat business and referral language dominate the feedback.
Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto
Blackstar's installation and repair teams earn consistent praise for arriving on schedule, protecting existing structures during work, and leaving properties spotless. Customers highlight staff like Pat, Pierre, Alex, and Horacio by name, noting their attentiveness to detail and communication. The gutter guards and eavestrough systems perform well years after installation, with minimal clogging or maintenance, and repair calls are handled quickly when issues arise.
Work spans gutters, soffit, fascia, and siding refinishes that customers say transform their homes' appearance. Jobs typically complete in one to two days. Reviewers mention competitive pricing relative to guards and materials included, and the team's meticulous approach around existing metal roofs, landscaping, and structural concerns builds trust even among property professionals.
Which should you pick?
Pick DVC Aluminum - Eavestrough, Soffit/Fascia, Siding if
- You want direct communication with one person (Vedran) from quote through completion
- You need the job scheduled and finished fast, often within a day or two of the quote
- You prefer a smaller operation with a track record of zero recent complaints
Pick Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto if
- You want a siding refinish that visibly updates your home's look, not just a repair
- You have adjacent structures (metal roofing, landscaping) that need careful protection during the work
- You value having named, familiar technicians on a larger crew for bigger or more involved jobs
Verdict
The right pick comes down to how you want the job run, not the score gap between them. DVC Aluminum fits homeowners who want a fast quote, a single accountable owner-operator, and a siding job wrapped up in a day or two. Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto fits jobs where a full refinish, careful site protection, and a coordinated crew matter more than speed alone.
Need help deciding which contractor suits your project?
Describe your roofing work once and compare quotes from qualified roofing contractor in Ontario.
When you submit a quote or contact form through this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work. We may earn a referral fee from these partners, but our rankings and scores are determined solely by our published method and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which company responds to quotes faster?
- DVC Aluminum is noted for responding to quote requests within 24 hours and often scheduling the work within days.
- Which is better for a full siding refinish rather than a repair?
- Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto's reviews specifically describe siding refinishes that change a home's appearance, alongside its gutter and eavestrough work.
- Does either company use a dedicated crew versus one person?
- DVC Aluminum is centered on owner Vedran handling jobs personally, while Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto works with named technicians like Pat, Pierre, Alex, and Horacio.
- How do their review volumes compare?
- DVC Aluminum has a 5.0 rating from 170 reviews, and Blackstar Aluminum Ltd Toronto has a 4.8 rating from 227 reviews.