High Skillz Roofing vs Ace Roofing: which fits your residential re-roof?
High Skillz Roofing and Ace Roofing Services are both genuine options for a residential roofing job in the North York area, and both come out nearly tied on our methodology. The real decision comes down to job size, how you want to be kept in the loop, and what happens if the crew finds something unexpected once the old roof comes off.
The differences that matter
- Crew size and pace. High Skillz leans on owner Arthur working the job directly and finishing many roof replacements in a single day, while Ace fields a larger 5-6 person crew that took on a full roof plus garage in 1.5 days.
- How you're kept informed. High Skillz reviewers describe Arthur explaining the work in person and answering questions on site, while Ace's Alex sends photo updates throughout the job so homeowners can follow along remotely.
- Handling hidden damage. Ace's reviews specifically call out a case of discovering rotten sheathing and fixing it properly rather than covering it up, a detail not present in High Skillz's review record.
- Storm and emergency response. High Skillz is praised for quick response to active leaks and emergency calls during storms, while Ace's reviewers cite next-day response for emergency storm repairs.
- Scope of specialty work. High Skillz's reviews center on full replacements and targeted repairs, while Ace's cover a wider named range including garage roofs, flat roofing, new vents, and chimney removal.
Side by side
- Google rating
- High Skillz Roofing Inc. | North York: 5 (208 reviews)
- Ace Roofing Services Inc: 5 (185 reviews)
- Services
- High Skillz Roofing Inc. | North York: roof repair, roofing contractor, residential roofing, flat roofing
- Ace Roofing Services Inc: roof repair, emergency 24 7, roofing contractor, residential roofing
- Best fit for
- High Skillz Roofing Inc. | North York: A single-structure home re-roof with the owner personally on site
- Ace Roofing Services Inc: A larger or multi-structure job (e.g., house plus garage) needing more hands
- Job updates
- High Skillz Roofing Inc. | North York: In-person walkthroughs and explanations from Arthur
- Ace Roofing Services Inc: Photo updates sent during the job
- Specialty work mentioned
- High Skillz Roofing Inc. | North York: Full replacements, targeted repairs, storm emergency response
- Ace Roofing Services Inc: Full replacements, garage roofs, flat roofing, new vents, chimney removal
- Verification
- High Skillz Roofing Inc. | North York: Google-verified
- Ace Roofing Services Inc: Google-verified
- Composite score
- High Skillz Roofing Inc. | North York: 94
- Ace Roofing Services Inc: 94
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
High Skillz Roofing Inc. | North York
Arthur and his crew consistently arrive on time, complete jobs (often roof replacements) in a single day, and leave sites spotless. Reviewers describe a straightforward, honest owner who explains work clearly, prices fairly, and stands behind the quality - with particular praise for quick responses to roof leaks and emergency calls during storms.
The team works through summer heat without complaint, takes minimal breaks, and handles both full replacements and targeted repairs with the same professional attention. Multiple reviewers cite the crew's friendliness and willingness to explain issues without upselling unnecessary work, making them a trusted choice for North York homeowners.
Ace Roofing Services Inc
Reviewers consistently praise Alex and his team for showing up on time, delivering quality work, and being upfront about costs and what needs fixing. One team came with 5-6 experienced roofers and completed a roof and garage in 1.5 days; another discovered rotten sheathing and fixed it properly rather than cutting corners. Alex sends photos during the job and keeps homeowners in the loop throughout. Cleanup is meticulous, pricing is described as fair and competitive, and he has refused unnecessary upsells.
The business handles a range of work from emergency storm repairs (next-day response) to full replacements, re-roofing after discoveries, garage roofs, flat roofing, new vents, and chimney removal. No complaints appear in the available reviews. Word-of-mouth is strong; neighbors recommend him, and reviewers say they would return for future jobs.
Which should you pick?
Pick High Skillz Roofing Inc. | North York if
- You want the owner, Arthur, personally directing and explaining the work as it happens
- Your job is a standard single-home replacement or repair you'd like wrapped up in a day
- You're dealing with an active leak or storm emergency and want a track record of fast on-site response
Pick Ace Roofing Services Inc if
- Your job spans more than one structure (house and garage) and benefits from a bigger crew working faster
- You'd rather get photo updates through the job than rely on an in-person walkthrough
- You're worried about what's under the shingles and want a contractor with a documented case of catching and properly fixing rotten sheathing
Verdict
Score and star rating won't separate these two: both sit around 94 with a perfect 5.0 average. The choice comes down to fit. High Skillz suits a homeowner who wants the owner himself on site, explaining things face to face, and moving fast on a single-structure job or a storm leak. Ace suits a bigger or more complex job, where a larger crew, photo-based updates, and a demonstrated habit of digging into (and fixing) hidden damage matter more than having the owner on the roof personally.
Need help deciding which contractor suits your project?
Describe your roofing work once and compare quotes from qualified roofing contractor in Ontario.
When you submit a quote or contact form through this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work. We may earn a referral fee from these partners, but our rankings and scores are determined solely by our published method and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which is faster for a standard residential re-roof?
- Both move quickly. High Skillz often completes single roof replacements in one day with Arthur on site, while Ace's larger 5-6 person crew handled a roof plus garage in 1.5 days.
- Which is better if my roof is actively leaking during a storm?
- High Skillz reviewers specifically praise fast response to leaks and emergency calls during storms; Ace also offers next-day response for emergency storm repairs.
- Which contractor is better documented for catching hidden problems like rotten sheathing?
- Ace's review record includes a specific case of discovering rotten sheathing and fixing it properly rather than covering it, a detail not present in High Skillz's reviews.
- Do both avoid pushing unnecessary work?
- Yes. Reviewers for both businesses describe honest assessments and no pressure to add work that isn't needed.