Integrity Roofers vs Right Choice Roofing and Repair: which fits an insulation-contractor job?
If you're weighing Integrity Roofers against Right Choice Roofing and Repair for work that touches insulation, roof, and attic systems, both are genuine contenders with strong local reputations. This comparison walks through the differences that actually matter for that kind of job, based on our methodology.
The differences that matter
- Depth of track record. Integrity Roofers has built a longer paper trail with 154 reviews and a high-confidence composite score, while Right Choice's 89.1 score carries medium confidence off a smaller 86-review base.
- Scope beyond the roof deck. Integrity Roofers' crew regularly works across roofing, skylights, eavestroughs, and siding, giving them more touchpoints on the ventilation and moisture-control details that affect attic insulation performance.
- Diagnostic and warranty backing. Integrity Roofers backs certified installations with 25-year labour and material warranties and is noted for diagnosing complex leaks beyond the original scope, which matters if hidden moisture is compromising insulation.
- Specialty repair skill. Right Choice is called out specifically for slate and complex repair work plus drone roof inspections, useful for spotting attic-level problem areas before they're opened up.
- Speed of access. Right Choice advertises next-day availability and Saturday service, while Integrity's reviews emphasize thoroughness and photo updates over stated turnaround speed.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Integrity Roofers: 4.8 (154 reviews)
- Right Choice Roofing and Repair: 4.9 (86 reviews)
- Services
- Integrity Roofers: roof repair, roofing contractor, residential roofing, flat roofing
- Right Choice Roofing and Repair: roof repair, emergency 24 7, roofing contractor, residential roofing
- Best for
- Integrity Roofers: Multi-system jobs where roof, eavestrough, and attic issues overlap
- Right Choice Roofing and Repair: A focused, urgent repair or a second opinion on a tricky roof problem
- Specialties
- Integrity Roofers: Roof replacements, skylights, eavestroughs, siding, warranty-backed installs
- Right Choice Roofing and Repair: Slate roofing, complex repairs, drone inspections
- Owner involvement
- Integrity Roofers: Named crew (Shay, Cory, Qais) handling jobs with consistent staff
- Right Choice Roofing and Repair: Owner-led (Frank) with direct, hands-on involvement
- Verification
- Integrity Roofers: Google-verified
- Right Choice Roofing and Repair: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Integrity Roofers: 90
- Right Choice Roofing and Repair: 89
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Integrity Roofers
Over many years Integrity Roofers has earned a strong track record for completing roof replacements, skylights, and repairs with meticulous attention to detail. Customers consistently praise named staff like Shay, Cory, and Qais for responsiveness, transparent quoting, and willingness to diagnose complex leak issues without pressure.
The crew demonstrates professional courtesy: they clean up after work, provide photo updates during jobs, and stand behind 25-year warranties on materials and labour. Reviewers note fair pricing relative to competitors, honest advice even on small repairs, and follow-through on warranty claims that require no fuss. Several long-term customers have returned multiple times for different services across roofing, skylights, eavestroughs, and siding.
Right Choice Roofing and Repair
Frank and his crew show up fast, fix roofs carefully, and send photos as they work. Customers mention his straightforward advice (he once recommended a second quote), reliable timekeeping, and tidy cleanup.
Which should you pick?
Pick Integrity Roofers if
- You need a contractor who can also handle eavestroughs or siding alongside roof and attic work
- A 25-year warranty on materials and labour matters for your budget
- You want a longer, high-confidence review history before committing
Pick Right Choice Roofing and Repair if
- You need next-day or Saturday service to stop an active leak fast
- Your roof involves slate or an unusually complex repair
- You'd value a drone inspection to scope attic-adjacent damage before work starts
Verdict
The right pick comes down to what the job actually needs. For work that spans the roof deck, ventilation, and attic-adjacent systems, Integrity Roofers' broader service range and warranty backing make it the steadier fit. For a fast-turnaround or specialty repair, especially one that benefits from a drone-eye view before anyone opens up the attic, Right Choice Roofing and Repair's owner-led speed and complex-repair focus is the better match.
Need help deciding which contractor suits your project?
Describe your roofing work once and compare quotes from qualified roofing contractor in Ontario.
When you submit a quote or contact form through this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work. We may earn a referral fee from these partners, but our rankings and scores are determined solely by our published method and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which contractor has the stronger review history?
- Integrity Roofers, with 154 reviews and a high-confidence composite score versus Right Choice's 86 reviews and medium-confidence score.
- Which one offers a warranty?
- Integrity Roofers is noted for 25-year labour and material warranties on certified installations; no warranty terms are mentioned for Right Choice.
- Who should I call for a fast repair?
- Right Choice Roofing and Repair advertises next-day availability and Saturday service, which suits urgent leak or repair situations.
- Does either specialize in complex roof types?
- Right Choice is specifically noted for slate roofing and complex repairs, plus drone roof inspections.