Solid Eavestrough vs Trades by Jack (LeafGuard): which fits your gutter job?
Solid Eavestrough and Trades by Jack | LeafGuard Mississauga both turn up as strong picks for eavestrough and gutter work, but they're built for different jobs: one is a small, warranty-backed repair and install crew, the other is an official LeafGuard dealer selling a specific gutter-guard system. Our methodology scores both highly, so the real choice comes down to what you actually need done.
The differences that matter
- Repairs vs. product install. Solid Eavestrough is set up for open-ended eavestrough repair, installation, and cleaning where the crew fixes problems they find on site, while Trades by Jack sells and installs the LeafGuard system specifically.
- Warranty terms. Solid Eavestrough backs its work with a stated two-year warranty, while Trades by Jack's summary flags product and warranty details as something customers need to check themselves.
- Track record at scale. Trades by Jack has 309 Google reviews at 4.8 stars versus Solid Eavestrough's 117 reviews at a perfect 5, so Trades by Jack has more volume proof while Solid Eavestrough has a cleaner average.
- Pricing structure. Trades by Jack advertises a specific promo ("Labour Installation: 75% Off"), whereas Solid Eavestrough is described as fair and transparent without a stated promo.
- Scope beyond gutters. Trades by Jack also installs Gemstone lighting alongside LeafGuard, showing a broader home-exterior product line, while Solid Eavestrough's team stays focused on eavestrough repair, installation, and cleaning.
Side by side
- Google rating
- Solid Eavestrough: 5 (117 reviews)
- Trades by Jack | LeafGuard - Eavestrough Installation Mississauga: 4.8 (309 reviews)
- Services
- Solid Eavestrough: eavestrough gutters, gutter service, roof inspection maintenance, roofing contractor
- Trades by Jack | LeafGuard - Eavestrough Installation Mississauga: eavestrough gutters, roof repair, flat roofing, residential roofing
- Best for
- Solid Eavestrough: Standard eavestrough repair, new installs, or gutter cleaning with a warranty backstop
- Trades by Jack | LeafGuard - Eavestrough Installation Mississauga: Homeowners specifically wanting a branded LeafGuard gutter-guard system
- Named crew
- Solid Eavestrough: Yaron, Elvir, Valon
- Trades by Jack | LeafGuard - Eavestrough Installation Mississauga: Angel Brothers, Genty (install); Joseph R., Scott (consultation)
- Proven longevity
- Solid Eavestrough: Two-year warranty stated on jobs
- Trades by Jack | LeafGuard - Eavestrough Installation Mississauga: Installations reported still performing after 3+ years, including through major rainstorms
- Verification
- Solid Eavestrough: Google-verified
- Trades by Jack | LeafGuard - Eavestrough Installation Mississauga: Google-verified
- Composite score
- Solid Eavestrough: 92
- Trades by Jack | LeafGuard - Eavestrough Installation Mississauga: 91
Within 3 points of each other, so treat them as effectively tied on overall quality. The choice below is about fit, not the score.
What reviewers say
Solid Eavestrough
Yaron and his team deliver eavestrough work that leaves customers with lasting confidence. Jobs start with same-day quotes, finish with photos for approval, and carry a two-year warranty. The crew tackles unexpected problems discovered on site, cleans debris thoroughly, and explains every step before charging fairly.
Staff members Yaron, Elvir, and Valon handle repairs, installations, and gutter cleaning with consistent professionalism. Customers return for repeat work and mention being pleasantly surprised by the honesty about what actually needs fixing versus what can wait.
Trades by Jack | LeafGuard - Eavestrough Installation Mississauga
Angel Brothers installers and the sales team deliver consistently polished work, from eavestrough replacements to Gemstone lighting. Customers praise the walk-throughs, cleanup, and no-mess installations; one reviewer noted the crew upgraded their earlier Gemstone system at no charge when standards improved. LeafGuard has performed through major rainstorms on multi-year-old installations, winning over neighbours. Across thirteen Gemstone reviews and six eavestrough or LeafGuard reviews, professionalism and product performance stand out as reasons customers recommend widely.
The business operates as the Official LeafGuard Dealer serving the GTA and beyond. Prices shown are "Labour Installation: 75% Off". Joseph R. and Scott handle consultations with detailed explanations; Angel Brothers and Genty lead installations. No complaints emerge in recent reviews; the only caveat concerns products and warranties, which the business explicitly advises customers to investigate.
Which should you pick?
Pick Solid Eavestrough if
- You want a same-day quote and a crew that fixes unexpected problems found on site, not just the original job
- You want a stated two-year warranty on the work itself
- You want straightforward eavestrough repair, installation, or cleaning without committing to a specific gutter-guard brand
Pick Trades by Jack | LeafGuard - Eavestrough Installation Mississauga if
- You specifically want a LeafGuard gutter-guard system installed by an official dealer
- You want a crew with a long public track record (309 reviews) and multi-year field performance in heavy rain
- You're also interested in Gemstone lighting and want one contractor for both
Verdict
The right pick depends on whether you're solving a problem or buying a product. Solid Eavestrough fits homeowners who need eavestroughs fixed, replaced, or cleaned by a crew that stands behind the work with a two-year warranty and flags extra issues honestly. Trades by Jack | LeafGuard fits homeowners who've already decided they want the LeafGuard gutter-guard system specifically, installed by a dealer with a long review history and reported multi-year performance, though warranty specifics are worth confirming directly.
Need help deciding which contractor suits your project?
Describe your roofing work once and compare quotes from qualified roofing contractor in Ontario.
When you submit a quote or contact form through this site, your enquiry may be shared with partner providers who can do the work. We may earn a referral fee from these partners, but our rankings and scores are determined solely by our published method and are never affected by referral fees.
FAQ
- Which has the higher composite score?
- Solid Eavestrough scores 92.1 versus 91.1 for Trades by Jack, a narrow gap that shouldn't override fit for your specific job.
- Which offers a clearer warranty on eavestrough work?
- Solid Eavestrough states a two-year warranty on its work; Trades by Jack's summary notes warranty details are a caveat customers should investigate themselves.
- Is Trades by Jack only for LeafGuard, or does it do general eavestrough work too?
- Its listing centers on LeafGuard installation and Gemstone lighting as an official dealer, so it's the better fit if you specifically want that branded system rather than general repair work.
- Which has more review volume?
- Trades by Jack has 309 Google reviews at 4.8 stars, compared to Solid Eavestrough's 117 reviews at 5 stars.