Roofing contractors in York (Toronto): ranked picks
York homeowners have a solid bench of GTA roofers to choose from, and the picks below are ranked using our methodology, which weighs Google ratings, review volume, recency, and sentiment. Every business here works across the wider Toronto area, so York jobs are part of their regular routes rather than a special trip.
York's mix of older detached homes, semis, and postwar bungalows means a lot of the calls here involve aging shingle roofs, chimney flashing, and eavestrough repairs, plus flat roofs on the area's rowhouses and low-slope additions. Several contractors below specifically mention ice dam removal and gutter rerouting, which matters on York's older housing stock during freeze-thaw season.
12 businesses, scored on rating, review volume, recency, sentiment and listing completeness. How we score › · View on map ›
At a glance
| # | Business | Score | Rating | From | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Allguard Roofing Toronto | 87 | 4.9 (55) | — | Roofs, chimneys, gutters |
| 2 | Alpine Roofing | 86 | 4.5 (604) | — | Flat roofs, big volume |
| 3 | Armstrong & Nelson Eavestroughing | 86 | 4.7 (81) | — | Eavestroughs, ice dams |
| 4 | Rosedale Roofing & Construction | 86 | 5 (30) | — | Full replacements, warranty |
| 5 | East GTA Roofers | 85 | 5 (25) | — | Flat roofs, chimney removal |
| 6 | Genesis Roofing & Contracting | 82 | 4.7 (82) | — | Established, documented work |
| 7 | Three Bro Squirrels Roofing Toronto | Shingle Roofs | Flat Roofs | Skylights | 79 | 5 (6) | — | Skylights, quick jobs |
| 8 | Glass First Class Ltd. | 77 | 4.6 (33) | — | Regular maintenance clients |
| 9 | Youbility Inc. | 65 | 4.9 (7) | — | roof repair |
| 10 | Major Remodelling | 59 | 5 (1) | — | roof repair |
| 11 | Rogers roofing & construction | 32 | — | — | roof repair |
| 12 | Well Trust Roofing & Landscaping | 26 | — | — | roof repair |
Ranked picks
Allguard Roofing Toronto
score 87/100High rating from 55 reviews with praise for fair pricing and on-time crews across the GTA.
Alpine Roofing
score 86/100604 reviews and a reputation for honest quotes and meticulous cleanup, including one client of 15+ years.
Armstrong & Nelson Eavestroughing
score 86/100Named techs Alex and Gael get praise for same-day booking and fixing winter ice dams with heating cables.
Rosedale Roofing & Construction
score 86/100All 30 reviews are five-star, with a 30-year warranty and fast turnaround on repairs and renovations.
East GTA Roofers
score 85/10025 reviews, all five-star, with reviewers highlighting spotless cleanup and zero hidden fees.
Genesis Roofing & Contracting
score 82/100Skilled named techs and photo updates on jobs, though a few repeat customers report follow-up delays.
Three Bro Squirrels Roofing Toronto | Shingle Roofs | Flat Roofs | Skylights
score 79/100Small but perfect review set, with customers noting faster turnaround and better value than competitors.
Glass First Class Ltd.
score 77/100Attentive staff and thorough cleanup for most jobs, though some report scheduling and pricing clarity issues.
Youbility Inc.
score 65/100All five available reviews rate Youbility 5 stars.
Major Remodelling
score 59/100Igor identified a chimney-area repair, explained the damage and long-term roof condition candidly, then completed a full replacement years later that proved his original assessment right.
Rogers roofing & construction
score 32/100Review evidence is limited for this listing.
Well Trust Roofing & Landscaping
score 26/100Limited review evidence available.